This, you say, is a blessing? V’zot Ha’brakhah
Ruth Bader Ginsburg died on Friday just before the Jewish New Year started. The significance of this was not lost on those of us who observe and follow the Jewish calendar.
So many of us mourn her death. We know how she held on so, so tight, through numerous bouts of cancer, to the very end, trying to make it through until the elections. But we ask, How could she die now? The dread associated with her death adds to the other dreads we’ve been carrying.
“V’zot Ha’brakhah,” begins the last Torah reading of the year: “This is the blessing that Moses, man of God, gave the Israelites before he died.”
There is a tradition that says that God arranges for the righteous, the tzaddikim, to die right before or after a new year begins. Ruth Bader Ginsburg was a woman of God, for sure.
But is this the blessing RBG is giving us? Her death??
Indeed, the new year is a turning point, and the tradition states that she will be able to help more from the “other side” in a more widespread way.
On Saturday, the first day of Rosh Hashanah, I went to the park and sat with my machzor, the prayer book for the High Holy Days, reviewing and preparing for the next day when I would be leading a Rosh Hahsanah service for my first time. I sat leaning against a huge boulder, the kind that inspires awe with its height and breadth, feeling the support and energy of this rock, and I thought, “This is what our prayers mean when we say to God, “You are the rock of our salvation.”
Rocks are solid. Ruth Bader Ginsburg was rock solid.
But the story doesn’t end there. To my amazement, as I sat there on the ground, my knees bent in front of me, a tiny yellow bird, probably a finch, flew over and landed directly on the toe of my shoe, not 3 feet from my face. It sat there looking at me, cocking and turning its head back and forth as birds do, and after about eight seconds, it left as quickly as it had come and disappeared into the tall bushes across the path. It was an experience I will never forget. It felt as if the bird were talking to me.
“What does it mean??” I asked a friend. And she looked it up for me: yellow birds carry messages of personal power, and they show up in your life when you feel defeated, are confronting someone who is suppressing your potential, or you are scared because you are starting something new. They come to remind us that we are stronger than we think and that we can make it through the storm.
I laughed with delight at the thought because I was feeling all these things personally at the moment: That there was someone trying to suppress my potential, that I do have a fear of being defeated, that I am starting something new, and it’s all more than a little bit scary. Could I make it through the storm?
The next day, I led that Rosh Hashanah service in Central Park to a group of almost 20 people. It was a great triumph for me. It was scary. I was not defeated.
But I’m not special. Everyone has way more power than they think. That bird came to remind me of mine, and I am passing on the message to you.
May we open ourselves to the indomitable spirit of RBG and allow it to flow through us and spread among us.
Thank you, Ruth, for the work you’ve done on earth. We will carry it on.
We have not been defeated.
Turtles, Snakes and T’Shuvah: Ha’azinu
In a dream I had a few days ago, I was looking down at a beautiful lake surrounded by rocks. The water was crystal clear and there were thousands and thousands of turtles of all sizes. They were sitting quietly on the floor of the lake, not moving, all clumped together, but with large open spaces of water in between the clumps. It was a calming though perplexing sight. I felt no fear, only awe. In the next part of the dream there were snakes. Not dangerous. Just there.
With their hard shells, turtles protect themselves well against attackers. They are powerful and solid. They plod along, slowly and steadily. They are patient. They win the race.
Snakes can represent transformation through the shedding of their skins.
For transformation to happen, space must be made for a different kind of work. Patience and a kind of psychic protection are necessary factors as we make our way through this difficult time.
Last week in the Torah, Moses was told by God that he would not be crossing over into the Promised Land with the rest of Israel. This week, in Ha’azinu, he makes his last speech of warnings to his people. They are still a stiff-necked people who have been unfaithful to the God that took them out of Egypt and showed them countless miracles. Moses chides them one last time, speaking harshly with warnings of dire endings, right before he dies.
Earthlings are still a stiff-necked people. We carry hard shells of protection against threat. It is difficult for us to believe in miracles and to have faith in God. It is difficult for us to change. Patience doesn’t come easily to us. We want it all now, in our lifetime. And making space, like cleaning out drawers of junk we collect, is something we avoid. It means we have to deal with old “stuff.”
The other day I was listening to two interviews with the Rev. Angel Kyodo Williams on Krista Tippet’s radio show, On Being. Williams is an African American Buddhist, an amazing writer and teacher.
Williams says we are living in a time of great potential and desperation; because there is so much potential, there is also desperation. But we are at a turning point; this time is different. This is not the same “go back to business as usual.” People are dismayed and disgusted. Enough of us have learned how intolerable it is to be intolerant, and we are willing to face what we have been unwilling to face before--to clean out that cluttered drawer.
And here’s the key; she says, “We know we must face this because it is intolerable to live in any other way than a way that allows us to be in contact with our full, loving, human self...We can not have a healed society, we can not have change, we can not have justice, if we do not reclaim and repair the human spirit.”
This means we have to do the hard inner work of “coming into the deep knowing of ourselves” because “that’s the stuff that bringing down systems of oppression is made of; capitalism, patriarchy, white supremacy, couldn’t survive if enough of us set about the work of reclaiming the human spirit---which includes the sense of humanity of the people that are the current vehicles for those very forms of oppression...
“We can take action, which is very important, but without the willingness to be flexible, open and to be moved by the truth of the ‘other,’ change is not transformative; the stroke of a pen can change it back.”
Finally, she explains that “our cultural impulse is to leap to change; We feel discomfort and want to leap over that inner work.” In other words, we don’t want to feel. It’s too painful. And anger often feels easier than love, so we become “angry activists.”
Moses, the older leader, must hand over his leadership to the next generation. He speaks harshly and angrily to the people. This is a people he has dedicated his life to, and he loves them, but he is unable to express that love.
Perhaps the Israelites need a new kind of leader—one who will show compassion for their slowness to change. One who makes time and space to pause and consider their struggles and to wait patiently as they plod along; one who helps them feel supported and protected and teaches them what love is really about, allowing for their imperfections and confusions about the world and what truth really is.
At this time in history, “we are being called to transcend our truth, with lower case letters, to finding Our Truth, with a capital 'O’ and a capital ‘T’,” says Williams.
Like the Israelites entering the new land, we are leaving something old behind. As Williams says, we will backslide; this is normal. But “something is dying in our culture, and that is the willingness to be in denial.”
If we keep doing the inner work required of us, we will slowly and steadily get there as a society.
May our inner work strengthen us and take us closer to true transformation in the coming year. Let’s be turtles and snakes and make time to do our t’shuva of returning to our true selves and repairing the human spirit.
Shana tova!
In Your Mouth and in Your Heart: Nitzavim
This week’s Torah reading, Nitzavim, begins: “You stand this day, all of you, before the Lord your God…”
Is it a coincidence that we read this right before Rosh Hashanah, asking for forgiveness, asking for another year?
“...I make this covenant, with its sanctions, not with you alone, but both with those who are standing here with us this day before the Lord our God and with those who are not with us here this day...”
This year more than ever, we are acutely aware of the many who are no longer with us today-- and the many who may not be with us next year.
“...Perchance there is among you some man or woman, some clan or tribe, whose heart is even now turning away from the Lord our God to go and worship the gods of those nations...sprouting poison weed and wormwood…”
Hmmm. Sprouting poison.
“...When such a one hears the words of these sanctions, he may fancy himself immune, thinking, “I shall be safe, though I follow my own willful heart.”
Hmmm again.
“...And later generations will ask---the children who succeed you, and foreigners who come from distant lands and see the plagues and diseases that the Lord has inflicted upon that land, all its soil devastated by sulfur and salt, beyond sowing and producing, no grass growing on it….”
But eventually, it seems, things will get better, because: ”Then the Lord your God will open up your heart and the hearts of your offspring to love the Lord your God with all your heart and soul, in order that you may live.”
Good news. We need it. And then some sarcasm?...
“...Surely, this instruction which I enjoin upon you this day is not too baffling for you, nor is it beyond reach. It is not in the heavens, that you should say, ‘Who among us can go up to the heavens and get it for us and impart it to us, that we may observe it?’ Neither is it beyond the sea, that you should say, ‘Who among us can cross to the other side of the sea and get it for us and impart it to us, that we may observe it?
“No, the thing is very close to you, in your mouth and in your heart, to observe it.”
Hmmm.
In your mouth.
And in your heart.
After writing and publishing my blog last week, I got some feedback from a couple of friends, and it made me worry about what had come out of my own mouth and the effect of my words on others. It had seemed so harmless---talking about my joy.
Only that wasn’t all I was talking about, and there were questions.
One friend said that a person of color might be offended by my making an analogy between the onslaught of curses from the bible and bullets coming from police against unarmed Black men and women. So I changed it. Just in case.
The other said she didn’t feel the nuance in my writing of my understanding of the political situation as she knows I understand it; I forgot to point out my awareness of the privilege I hold by being able to escape the city at all---ever!
She knows that I grew up going to (integrated) New York City public schools (an extreme rarity, then and now, in the most segregated public school system in the country--have you listened to the podcast, “Nice White Parents”? If not, you should).
This friend also knows I was taught to be sensitive to the history of the Black and brown students I went to school with, and to understand the anger they expressed toward white, blonde, little me and my siblings.
She knows I had parents who taught me to argue against those who said, “‘They’ need to just get over it. Slavery ended a long time ago.”
She wanted to hear this nuance in my writing. She thought it was important. I couldn’t sleep that night, I was so concerned. In the morning, I made some more changes.
Should I worry about every single word that comes out of my mouth? If I do that, I won’t end up saying anything; I need to have a thicker skin; someone will always find something to criticize.
If, on the other hand, I don’t worry enough, I’ll be like people I don’t want to be like. And how deep do I want my message to be?
Over the past couple of years, I’ve heard people complain: “Everyone has gotten so sensitive; you can’t say anything these days without worrying about offending or making someone feel ‘unsafe.’
“Feeling uncomfortable,” they say, “is a part of life; if you’re not uncomfortable, then you’re not growing.”
All true.
Everyone is very sensitive right now. And for good reason.This culture of “honesty” we are living in is hurting many people in real ways.
And it’s important to have the uncomfortable conversations that help us grow. We are on a steep learning curve at this moment in history, and a lot--more than ever--is being asked of us. It’s hard. Many times, we’re not going to get it right, despite our best intentions.
Besides trying my best to get the words right, I can be more patient and forgiving of others who aren’t getting it right, even those I completely disagree with. The world is a confusing, scary place for us all right now.
I can’t do anything about other people’s mouths and hearts, and it’s really, really frustrating, but I can do something about my own. I want to know that I have tried my hardest to check my own mouth and my own heart, when I stand before God this year on Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur.
Surely, this is not too difficult or baffling.
Joy and Snapping Turtles: Ki Tavo
Today it’s my birthday, and I’m joyful, but that’s not really why I’m joyful. Last week I was not joyful, and it wasn’t because it wasn’t my birthday. It was because I was feeling a lot of pain, and also trying not to. A friend and colleague was dying an untimely death in a crazily short amount of time. I wanted to feel grateful and joyful that I was alive, but I just felt really sad.
Like pain, joy is something I can’t seem to control very well. I reach for joy daily as part of my spiritual practice, but it feels very elusive. Usually it just comes spontaneously, but it’s always a goal: To Live in Joy. This is what we’re told we should do to praise God. It says so in this week’s Torah reading, too. And I want to do it for my family, because it makes life easier for them, and for myself, too, because it makes my life easier as well.
The parsha Ki Tavo is a continuation of the preparation of previous weeks for “Entering the Land,” “Ki Tavo---When you enter,” it begins. It feels like it should be a joyful reading, because the Israelites are about to enter the Land of Milk and Honey, but it’s so incredibly painful to read. It’s just an onslaught of curses---forewarnings of all the terrible things God will bring upon us if we don’t walk in God’s ways.
As I read it, it felt like a series of bullets entering my body, pow pow pow pow pow!
Then there are the blessings to counter them. If you walk in God’s ways...
On Sunday, for the first time in six months, I left the city and got to be together with my husband, my children, my sister and her daughter, my twin brother and his family, at his house in the country. It was a perfect day. The weather was perfect, sandwiched in between cloudy, stormy, humid, hot days. Perfect temperature. Low humidity. Sunny. A Goldilocks day, as a friend described it.
I got to go swimming in a stream on the spur of the moment with my sister. First we just put our toes in the water. But the cold, living waters were calling to us, so after a bit of debate, we simply threw our bodies into it. The joy was great and it was incredibly healing.
When we got back to the house, I shared the news excitedly with my nephew. He smiled mischievously: “That’s great! Did you see the snapping turtle?”
I’m glad we didn’t see the snapping turtle. I’m glad I didn’t remember about the snapping turtle, or I wouldn’t have dared go in.
After this idyllic day of perfect weather, delicious food (that my brother cooked on the grill), playing and fun, and no fights (I think those days are gone. This younger generation in my family seems to have figured out what’s important, I’m happy to report), we got off the train at 125th Street in Harlem, and had to face the snapping turtle after all.
As we waited for a taxi, the homelessness, the mental illness, the drug problems, the neglect and the racism of our society were all hanging out right in front of the station with us, and it was really painful. The contrast with the incredible privilege I’d just been able to participate in, and that I get to regularly, was stark, and the irony of the situation was not lost on me. And I wished only to escape back to the idyllic world we’d just come from, and to feel the joy.
Such is the struggle posed to us every day: to face the pain that snaps at us constantly and to make our society a place of joy for everyone. We are to hear the call of the Shofar (the ram’s horn we blow in this season) daily during this month of Elul in preparation for the New Year. It is a call to wake up and make room for change—in ourselves, the way we live, the way we treat others and the earth.
At the same time, we are enjoined to find the joy, even in the midst of the pain.
I’m no saint. I can’t seem to live in that place of joy, though try I might. I’m just so damn human.
Yet, it’s another intention I have for the Jewish New Year: to really be aware and grateful every day to be alive, and to find the joy in that. Simply put: to fulfill the commandment of living in joy, because it is thus that we are praising God.
Sometimes I get glimpses of it, like this past Sunday, and it stays with me for a good little while, like today. I know the snapping turtle is there in the background, but I can choose to forget it’s there for just a short time so I can have some peace.
And that’s okay.
I understand that it is my privilege that allows me to escape at all. The question is, do I dare to continue to dip my toe—or throw my body—into some joyful waters if the possibility arises, forgetting the snapping turtle for at least a little while. For my own sake and for my family during this very trying time, I have to if I can. But also, I can’t help others and the world if I’m in a constant state of agitation. So I’ll keep that intention.
Happy Elul.
Responsibility, Blame, Guilt and Vows:“Ki Teitzei”
As we enter the month of preparation for the Days of Awe, our job is to do a lot of inner soul work and searching; the idea is that we should feel ready to make the vows we will make when the new year starts.
Vows are not to be taken lightly. In this week’s Torah reading, Ki Teitzei, we are told that if you make a vow and don’t follow through---and soon---you’re guilty (you have “Chet,” like the famous High Holy Day prayer, “Al Chet”).
If you don’t make the vow, however, you’re okay.
Promises are really important. Just like what you wish for, be careful what you promise.
Let’s talk about responsibility for a minute.
Doctors are responsible for doing their best to save a person’s life, but it stops there. They’re not God, and they can’t promise. They’re liable if they do promise and then things don’t turn out okay.
But how do we separate responsibility from blame and guilt?
Our inner critical voices are so strong. Throughout this pandemic, but even before, people have been telling me, “Be gentle with yourself.”
If you’re lucky, you’ve been in touch with people who tell you the same thing--and regularly!
We carry these harsh voices within us from childhood, and even earlier. Our whole society is set up that way: “you didn’t study enough; you’re not smart enough; you weren’t paying attention; you didn’t listen to me; you aren’t grounded; you aren’t taking care of yourself your body your house your kids your money; just relax; you’re too stressed out; you’re too negative; just ignore it; get over it; move on and forget about it…”
Aaaaaaaarghhhhhhh!!! The admonitions can go on and on and on and on, like this sentence and that song from my teenage years.
All these things may be true or even good advice, but does that make us guilty?
And how often do we say such things to other people without intending to make them feel guilty, but the effect is just that?
One of the kindest things a friend recently said to me was, “I don’t think you do anything to cause your migraines. I think they just happen.” I was going through my mental list out loud of all the possible things I’d done to cause my latest one. (This is a (bad) habit of mine each time I have a migraine.)
“I don’t think you do anything to cause them.”
She said it so casually, but the impact was so immense that it still pops into my head weeks later each time I get a migraine. And it lessens the stress, if not the pain.
I’m not to blame. What a relief.
This week’s Torah tells us lots of things we’re responsible for, and migraines are not one of them.
To give a few examples from the Torah: We’re responsible for giving back the animals that belong to a neighbor if we find them; marrying your dead brother’s wife so you know she’s taken care of; protecting a run-away slave; making sure you give full inheritance to a son whose mother you don’t love; leaving pickings in your orchard for the poor person; not taking too much from a field that’s not yours; listening to the priest’s instructions to keep a skin condition from spreading; crying out if you’re being raped.
We are all responsible, but very few of us are actually guilty.
If the priest doesn’t give you the right advice, you can’t be guilty of not containing the spread of the affliction. And if you cry out but you’re in a place where no one can hear you, it’s not your fault for not being heard.
My friend had no idea of the impact of her words, but they were heard, probably because of the casual, gentle way she said them. It just felt like a fact. She didn’t need to yell or admonish me.
We all know what we have to do. We know our responsibilities.
Here are some goals I like for the coming year:
To be the gentle, casual voice that reminds myself and others, “It’s not your fault.”
To not make unrealistic vows that I can’t carry out, whether they’re personal or for the world
To seek out those who carry those gentle messages and make them my regular company.
To keep crying out, in whatever ways I can, for what I need and for what is needed in the world, but to let go of any guilt for what I seem unable to change.
Because we are all responsible, but only a few are truly guilty.
“Shoftim:” T’shuvah, Returning and Turning Points
At what point do we decide, collectively and individually, that it’s been enough? And what does that “enough” look like?
I’ve been thinking so much about the coming month of Elul, our Jewish entry into turning/change and returning--returning to our true nature, returning to “God.”
In this week’s Torah reading, Shoftim, the Israelites are given many laws they are to follow as they establish themselves in a new land, to live a new life. It is here that we find the famous line, “Justice, Justice shall you pursue: Tzedek tzedek tirdof.”
Great idea!
Some of the laws sound really good, like, when you take over another people’s land, don’t chop down or destroy any fruit bearing trees, especially not for building your houses; have respect for the tree and the life it gives.
Another good law: if you are a king, don’t amass too much silver and gold.
And another: Don’t go back to Egypt--to Mitzrayim, the “narrow place,” for any reason!
Other laws sound really harsh to modern sensibilities, like the punishment for worshiping other gods when you’ve been told not to. Since you should know better, because you’ve been told again and again, you get stoned to death for doing so.
Meanwhile, in our “First World” country, we chop down trees and destroy forests to build pipelines, and we still have the death penalty, so let’s not get too far ahead of ourselves. We’re still living in the narrow place.
What is the turning point where people make the collective decision, “No more destruction, no more torture, no more abuse! Enough!” As individuals, it could be in a job, a relationship, a marriage, or a way of behaving, thinking, being.
Like, you’re no longer going to live with fear and panic.
Yeah, that’s mine: living with fear and panic--not always, by any means, but it’s become very prominent for me again these past months since the beginning of the pandemic and being sick.
Those close to me know that I struggle with this, but it’s really hard to put it out there to the general world. There’s so much lack of or misunderstanding and judgment still in the world and in our culture when it comes to people with anxiety and any kind emotional problems or mental illness. I judge myself.
Yet repeatedly this week I was reminded in different contexts that I am not alone, that there are countless other people who know exactly how I feel because they also experience or have experienced the same thing; I am not alone.
At the same time, for each of us who suffers in this way, or in any way, can there be a moment when we wake up and say, “Enough! I can’t live this way anymore! I’m sick of it and I reject it!” Maybe it was a gradual, creeping awareness, or maybe it took a lot of work.
What is that work?
I think it’s about building faith and trust that we will be okay, that the world will be okay, that this is not the end. The reminder is there again in Torah: “Do not bow down to false gods. I’ve been telling you this and you’re not listening.” God is frustrated with us. He wants us to start paying attention. We are to be stoned to death if we don’t.
Sounds harsh, no?
Often we think of false gods as money and possessions, but false gods can be anything that takes our attention away from what really matters. Fear mongering and panic are what sells the news and it takes us away from love of other people and the earth and the inter-connectedness of us all. In the narrow place of fear and panic, we forget that God is One.
Sometimes we need to be clobbered over the head to start paying attention. Or maybe we can start paying attention to the little things that happen all the time. For me, each week there seems to be a theme to the messages that come into my life. They come from seemingly disparate places and voices, and it always surprises me, but then I think, I guess that’s God’s way of communicating with me. “You are not alone; countless other people know exactly how you feel.” God is One.
I don’t want any more clobbering.
When I live from a less constricted place, the fear and panic diminish, and sometimes even go away completely. I know I’m not alone in my panic and fear, but I’d rather be not alone in my faith.
If we build faith together, we can come out of the narrow place and put away the stones. Or use them to build houses. Then we don’t need to chop down any more trees.
“R’eih;” Seeing Blessings within Curses
Who’s to say and how do we know what’s a blessing and what’s a curse...if we can allow ourselves to ask the question, so taboo? Especially when people are suffering: “How dare you say that what I’m going through might be a blessing?”
Like the story of a man who has mishap after mishap in his life. In a long line of curses and condolences, his son finally breaks his leg. Yet a war breaks out shortly, and the only young man who isn’t hauled off is the one with the broken leg. A curse is turned into a blessing.
Does it come down to the way we look at things? The way we “see”?
The title of this week’s Torah reading, and the very first word, is R’eih: See: A commandment.
Last week, I said that the world requires us to live with our eyes wide open. The reality is a painful sight: Coronavirus, illness, death, unemployment, homelessness, deportation, our president, earthquakes, hurricanes, no electricity, explosions...
How could any of this ever be a blessing? Isn’t it much more realistic--aren’t we seeing more clearly--when we talk about how horrible everything is? My depressive father used to say with a little chuckle, teasing himself a bit, “Those who are depressed see the world as it really is. Those who aren’t, are delusional.” There’s even a psychological term for it: Depressive Realism.
What a depressing time we’re in. It seems that finally, more and more people are seeing the world as it really is. Should we say “yay” to that? It feels scary and cruel to state; The pandemic has been a curse, for sure, yet so many blessings have come out of it.
It was a curse to get sick and live in fear of losing my husband, and to continue to suffer the after-effects of Corona, yet a blessing to be able to see a clear path in a different direction, directly caused by the suffering. This new vision has allowed for an opening of space for new things to happen, creating something new for myself and separating from toxic relationships.
It’s a curse not to be able to gather and sing together in our communities, yet it’s been a blessing to be able to explore other communities far away--because of the internet--that thing we’ve said was also a curse.
Not being able to see family and friends feels like a curse, yet it has made certain bonds stronger and deeper on a new level, especially with my children.
Our curse of a president has brought the blessing of forcing so many people out of complacency--seeing more clearly what needs to be done in the world and acting on it.
The other day, after hurricane Isaias hit, I went walking in Central Park. As I passed one of my favorite spots, what I like to call “my meadow,” I saw that one of my favorite trees had been ripped out of the ground from its roots. It’s a spot I discovered in the spring when I was beginning to recover from COVID, with a beautiful ground covering underneath, a spot I chose to practice yoga and Qi Gong--a healing place for me. Surrounded on one side by very tall trees, it seemed highly unlikely to be a target of the hurricane winds, so low. Yet there it lay languishing on its side, its wide bushy branches spread out and leaning on the ground. I went over to it and touched its branches and cried.
In this week’s Torah reading, the bible tells us to destroy all the sites where other gods have been worshiped, whether on mountaintops or under luxurious trees. What a strange thing to imagine; altars under luxurious trees? Mountaintops? Sure. But under luxurious trees? Why luxurious?
It seems clear that we are to leave the tree alone and just destroy the false gods and altar, but it still felt sad as I thought of the destruction of this favorite little tree in a spot that felt incredibly luxurious in this big, hot city full of concrete where I’m stuck because of the pandemic.
The injunction is a continuation of last week’s parsha; walk in the way of God, a One God of Unification, not many gods separate from each other and us; wake up to the fact that all of life is connected; live with humility, not arrogance; know the source of the abundance in your life, for it is not your own hands that created it; know that this earth is a gift and treat it as such.
Is it unrealistic to see the blessings in the curses? Is it unrealistic to think that we can change the world--even after all this? Perhaps. But I’d rather be delusional and live with hope and belief that we can change the world, as Rabbi Michael Lerner, author of Revolutionary Love, A Political Manifesto to Heal and Transform the World, among other revolutionary works, says. I’d rather believe in the infinite possibility of transformation. That is God to me: the possibility of transformation for the whole world, even with the pain.
Maybe there is a blessing in the fall of that beautiful little tree. Maybe it has made space for something else that I can’t yet see.
“Eikev,” Pilot Lights and Firecrackers: Spiritual Lessons for living in what seem like hopeless times
A year ago at this time, I supported a bas mitzvah student of mine, a certain Rebecca who is not mine but has the same curly hair and name as my own younger daughter, as she stood in front of our congregation and spoke prophetically about the urgency of the climate and Greta Thunberg; if we live in the ways of God, take care of each other and the earth, then we will make it into the Land of Milk and Honey.
Continuing from her message: We can help the earth, and all that lives on earth, find its balance again if we remove the layers we have protecting our hearts.
I suppose we are all afraid to feel too much; if we allow ourselves to start crying, maybe we’ll never stop. Right?
This morning, after a week of excruciating pain in my head, I may have reached a new level of acceptance--not about the climate, no, but about my challenges...
...Acceptance that I will not be “balanced” or find any kind of complete balance during this time...that I will continue to have migraines that will incapacitate me for periods of time...that I will continue to feel stuck, just like everyone else...that I will continue to struggle find balance and to counter this feeling of stuckness with positive messages.
You get the idea. I know you have your own list of “shoulds” that could be turned into a kind of acceptance or surrender.
And so it should be--this continued struggle. If I didn’t continue to struggle, it would mean I was giving up. Instead, I choose hope, as I said last week in my blog post, No Room for Despair; there is no room for despair.
Following is another hopeful message, this time from the late congressman John Lewis’s words in an old interview with Krista Tippet on NPR’s On Being. He talked about pilot lights (as in the little constant flame in the old gas stoves) as opposed to firecrackers.
I paraphrase: “You tell us to wait. You tell us to be patient. We can not wait. We can not be patient. We want our freedom now...But that has to be balanced. Pace yourself. You don’t change the world and society in a few days. It’s better to be a pilot light than a firecracker.”
In other words, be an “Aish Tamid”--a continuous flame that is never allowed to go out.
But what about the environment, you say--I say! We’re running out of time! Haven’t you heard?? The arctic is not just warming, it’s burning up!!
True. Yet, I must choose hope. I have no choice.
Some of you may believe in people who get messages from the spirit world, some may not. No matter. Again, I think of this as a choice, like believing in God. (There’s no proof either way, so why not believe in the thing that makes you happier and live longer and healthier? I quote from Dr. Mario Martinez in his book, The MindBody Code, 2014—I read it a few years ago and consider it an important part of my spiritual journey.)
I have a friend who forwards me monthly messages and predictions from a certain Sara Wiseman. Sara is not the only one carrying messages that humanity is waking up, and that we’re close--really close--to things changing for the better, including the earth healing itself.
The message is that the pain we are experiencing, if we allow ourselves to, physical or emotional, is that of humanity “burning karma,” not just for our own families, not just for recent generations but for the whole world. It says that we are past the worst. After all, how much more “worst” can we take? The spirit world asks that we live with our eyes wide open, allowing ourselves to feel the pain, for with this kind of living, we will achieve the healing the world needs.
In this week’s Torah reading, Eikev, we are asked to cut away, or circumcise, the foreskin of our hearts, the extra layer that we use to protect ourselves from feeling the pain, and live in God’s ways.
I want--I have to believe that humanity as a whole is waking up, that real change (revolution?) is around the corner, and that this pain, this personal pain I experience each time I struggle with migraines, each time there is nothing, I mean nothing, I can take that “works,” is giving birth to something truly new.
There is really nothing we can take that will cover up the pain we are all feeling right now as a collective. I mean nothing.
So let’s be like pilot lights, take care of ourselves, keep seeking balance, for our bodies and our activism, and live with our hearts and eyes wide open.
Let’s strip away any extra layers that make us blind or unfeeling.
Yes, protect ourselves from overload, but also allow ourselves to feel and see. The more we do this, the more we are helping our own selves and the world.
Tisha B’Av: No Room for Despair
I’ve never been much into Tisha B’av. Maybe nobody is. After all, it brings us into a place of mourning over a Temple from two thousand years ago that we can’t really relate to if we’re not from a religious community. And if we’re part of the progressive Jewish community, then we are forced to face the pain of today’s society.
These days, we’re a bit overloaded, no exaggeration.
But I was pleasantly surprised yesterday when my 20-year-old daughter read to me from one of her books about Jewish stuff. This one was a book about Tisha B’av.
Being in a funk myself, I was pleasantly inspired.
There is the story of a Holocaust survivor, gaunt from starvation, who approaches a Jewish lieutenant who comes to the ghetto. The ghetto resident tells the story of a rabbi Elchanan Wasserman whom he had approached in the ghetto and asked in despair, “What is the meaning of this?”
Rabbi Elchanan proceeded to tell him a parable of a man who came to a farmer who wants to learn about farming. (Said man seems extremely naive, but so it goes with parables sometimes.)
The farmer takes him through the process month by month and the man is horrified each time by what he sees and experiences. First, a field is cleared of its beautiful flowers and grasses, stripped bare and left ugly. But then neat rows are made and things begin to grow. So it goes every step of the way, as the wheat grows and is cut down and beaten to separate the seeds from the sheethes, all the way to creating a loaf that is placed in the oven to be “burned!” Each time, the man feels like he is witnessing senseless destruction. Each time he is told to be patient and wait and see.
When the beautiful loaf of bread comes out of the oven, the man in the parable finally sees clearly what he could not along the way. We are told by Rabbi Wasserman that we can not understand God’s ways until we look back and see the entire process.
We, too, are having a hard time seeing the big picture. It all feels so, so horrible and hopeless. When Trump was elected, as scary as it was, I thought it was a good thing that we were being forced to confront the issues that would stay swept under the rug if we continued with the status quo, comfortably in denial.
As scary as things are, they’re getting scarier. We have a president who “doesn’t like to lose,” and may refuse to concede if he does. (On Democracy Now! Noam Chomsky points out what we are facing is unprecedented in history, even in dictatorships. To listen, go to democracynow.org, or here’s the link on youtube.
This alone is terrifying enough, but it’s piled on top of everything else (need I make a list?). I would argue that we are living through the worst times on earth on a global level and I’m not alone in saying that. It’s enough to leave us in despair.
Yet, the bigger picture over the arc of history has yet to be revealed, as much as it feels like we haven’t made any progress and we are going backwards. In the grand scope of things, the history of this country is very, very short.
The protesters in Portland are not giving up. There is no room for despair. They need us.
From Breishit to Devarim: From our beginnings to the Promised Land
I remember back in September when the year was just starting out. I was on a Jewish chant retreat with Rabbi Shefa Gold. It was Breishit, the first parsha of the Book of Genesis. The question was, what were we committing to for the year? What were we each making a choice to do differently? I committed out loud to a small group of people that I would begin leading my own services. Voila! I’m doing it! And much much more than I ever imagined. Yay!
Looking back, none of us had any idea that this year was going to be SO much different from anything imaginable. It’s become cliche to say that. The pandemic has caused many of us to change the direction of our lives…to see things differently…to open our eyes to things we didn’t see before. It certainly did for me.
Now we come to the part of the Torah where the Israelites finally get to enter the Promised Land, after forty years of wandering in the desert. Moses retells the whole story, detail by detail, place by place, again, as if telling the story of a trauma.
We too, are in the middle of a trauma, and we too, need to keep telling our stories. I find that I need to tell my personal story of Covid 19 less and less, which is a good sign, but the trauma has not passed and is not passing yet.
Black Lives Matter, murders by police, abductions by the military in our own country—and the weather is tied in, of course. It’s been unseasonably hot and humid in the northeast as in many parts (remember when they stopped saying “unseasonably” on the radio? I guess they realized there was no point anymore). It’s impossible to stay fit and also stay hydrated when I go out in this weather, and migraines often accompany this weather for me.
Last night there were huge booms of lightning hit the ground right outside my window—more “severe weather”—shaking the city ground and my building. And with those booms, my migraine raged. It felt like a biblical level of God’s rage, even though I don’t believe in an anthropomorphic God.
The question I was left with from the week’s Torah reading was, are we like the Israelites, finally entering the Promised Land, or are we like Moses, who never gets to?
When I think of all the work we humans still have to do before we get the “reward” of the “Promised Land,” it makes me think of the flow of the year, from our beginnings to the “end” of the story.
Are we living in the flow? How do we make sure we are? We flow in and out constantly, losing touch with what’s most important, and then remembering again, or being rudely awakened to it if we don’t remind ourselves. We are definitely in a rude awakening right now.
Our work is to keep trying. Just keep trying. Do our spiritual work of reconnecting when we lose the connection--with each other, the earth, and all living creatures. Constantly. Every day. In some way. We keep practicing.
If we can learn to live in the flow more often than not, maybe we’ll make it to the Promised Land.
Let’s keep trying.
Torah & Dreams: Lizards and Mourning Doves, Part II
A few days later after this dream of iguanas, I had a healing session with a friend. I’d just finished a book called Buried Rivers; A spiritual Journey into the Holocaust, which I felt had an important message for me. My friend intuited, and I agreed, that I needed to heal some ancestral stuff and free myself of old fears passed down through generations of living in terror. My friend calls this a Divine Mother, or Shechinah, healing. It was profound and cleansing.
The next day I got a terrible headache that turned into a three-day migraine.
Migraines for me are always an opportunity for deep spiritual work. The pain, the pulsating stabs that won’t subside, no matter what I take, drive me to tears. This time, waves of grief passed through me that came out in loud sobs throughout the second day, I felt like I was releasing generations of grief over loss.
The next day, as I was still recovering, I spoke to a friend who is a medium. We were talking about a friend from our synagogue, Evelyn, who just died a couple of weeks ago at 92 of pancreatic cancer. And Evelyn came with a message for us: “Live with a clear and open heart. Start living that way now. It will change your life. I’m not talking out of my ass.” We laughed and cried.
And I asked Evelyn that if she visited me again, would she please show a sign.
Shabbat morning, as I was just waking up, still in that liminal space, I remembered it was Shabbat, and quietly said to the world, “Shabbat Shalom,” and tears immediately sprung to my eyes. Would it be a Shabbat Shalom? And July 4th--what’s to celebrate? A history of continuous and continuing oppression of Black people, stark inequality on the rise, Coronavirus on the rise, I feel so much rage, and no, I would not be going to synagogue or seeing friends or being in community.
Then I heard the sound of a mourning dove outside my window. I often see them in the park, and they’re my favorite bird besides blue jays, but never do they come into the courtyard below my window. So I went to make sure that’s what I was hearing, and it was.
A couple of minutes later, as I’m wiping my tears still, I hear it louder. I look up and there it is perched on my window sill, inside the little slit between the open glass and the screen. It could have much more easily landed beside the open window on the other part of sill, but it comfortably flew in between the small opening to walk back and forth, cooing and looking in at me through the screen. I immediately thought of Evelyn, and tears came up again. Is it her?
I go to look up doves this time as spirit animals. This is what I found on two different websites:
Doves lay two eggs. This is apparently unique and important.
They are ground eaters so they remind us to stay connected to the earth--the feminine aspect of the Divine, which is linked to creative energy.
The mourning dove in particular invokes new “waters of life” from its mournful cry. It reminds us that new waters can still flow and new life is still possible even in the worst of times.
The mourning dove reminds us that it’s fine to mourn what has passed, but we must remember to awaken to the promise of the future.
This is a bird of prophecy. It can help you see what you can give birth to in your own life.
It reminds you to soar; to know when to move your wings and when to allow the wind to take you to new heights; when to surrender and let the wind support you.
Or stop and take a deep breath; let go of the turmoil surrounding you and take time to find peace within. Reality is shifting in ways you never thought possible.
Finally, it may be a sign that you need to purify your thoughts, because you attract what you focus on.
Words associated with the dove are: ascension, peace, gentleness, grace, holiness, hopefulness, love, peace, promise, prophecy.
Evelyn’s message, over and over again, was: “Do the hard spiritual work while you’re here. You can do it when you’re gone, but it’s better when you’re here. It’s worth it.”
May we all find ways of living with a clear and open heart. It will change our lives. And I’m sure it can change the world.
And I’m not talkin’ out of my ass.
Spiritual Messages from Torah and Dreams: Living Waters, Lizards, Broken Pencils, and Mourning Doves
It started with a dream I had last week, during the weekly Torah reading called Korach, when Korach and his supporters are swallowed up by the earth for rebelling against Moses, and the “Living Waters/Chayim Mayim,” are used as the final purification rite for those in contact with the dead.
What is dead now? What needs to be purified?
The dream:
Two Iguanas with spikes on their backs. They’re somehow my pets. I feel responsible for them and I don’t want them. I’m afraid of them. I also realize they’re not on leashes, so they can easily get away, which would make me very happy. I’m sitting on a rock, the two of them in front of me, one closer. It tries to snatch my pencil, an old #2 yellow pencil, but I kick at it. It doesn’t succeed in taking the pencil but it does break it in two pieces. (That image still floats in my mind, of a broken #2 pencil floating in the air.) Then the two iguanas slip into the beautiful water to go hunting, and I’m free! I go prancing off to hike in the forest, overjoyed by my freedom.
Why two? Why Iguanas? Why the pencil?
I hope I don’t offend anyone with what may seem like cultural appropriation, but a few years ago I was introduced to the idea of Native American Medicine Cards and Spirit Animals. I include my experience with these because I believe that all spiritual paths lead to the same place ultimately, we are all fundamentally connected, and I have found them useful and enlightening. I include my experience with the utmost respect--and my story wouldn’t be a story without them--or it would definitely not be as good.
I read about the medicine of lizards first. According to my book, they come in dreams, are the medicine of dreamers and can help you see differentiate the shade from the shadow. The shadow can be your fears, hopes, or the very thing you are resisting, and it is always following you around. For me, they were the fears that are always following me around--about my health mostly. The broken pencil was the old story of my childhood, and the fears I inherited from generations of hypochondria as a survival mechanism, I’m guessing. Broken because it’s an old story, but it’s still mine and can’t be taken away from me. I can now write a new story. I am free to do that.
We talked about my dream during a Zoom Shabbat morning service last week and someone brought the idea of two doves into the conversation as a somehow substitute for the iguanas. Then I responded, and another person pipes up and says, just as you were talking, two doves landed on my deck.
Cont. Spiritual Lessons from Coronavirus
Monday, April 20, 2020
How do I savor this feeling of a new lease on life? How do I stay in this place of gratefulness?
I have been trying to live in that place for years now, and I see how quickly the feeling starts to fade, especially as I wake up still feeling shitty more days than not.
This morning as I woke up, instead of just saying “Modah Ani” and moving on to the next prayer, I took the time to sit in bed for a couple of minutes and chant it, really thinking about the words, letting a melody come to me. You see, I don’t usually think I “have the time.” I have an “agenda,” after all. I’ve got to get up and move into my “morning routine” more quickly: the yoga, qi gong, davenin. (As it is, I feel much too privileged to have the time for all this at all. My children are grown, I don’t currently have a job, I’m in school full time. Feelings of guilt abound. I know, I know, so many people would give anything to be living my life. Is it like survivor’s guilt? Anyway, not the subject at hand…)
Of course I’m aware that the moment of waking up, washing my hands and going to the bathroom are part of my morning routine, but I so often rush through it. That’s the thing with routine. We can easily fall into doing it unconsciously.
On the other hand, it’s regular practice that strengthens a routine. If we do exercise regularly, our muscles get stronger. But so often do people put on music or watch a show while doing exercise.
If we’re not aware, we might do the same with prayer. Our own distraction can lead to unconscious prayer. I struggle with this all the time, every day in fact. I am constantly looking for a balance.
Something that works for me often and especially this week is experimenting with throwing my whole body into prayer, shuckling, but from my knees, especially when I don’t have the energy to stand. On the “baruch” of a prayer, I really throw my body forward, and sometimes stick my nose into my prayer book. The shuckling I’ve observed in many Orthodox men is my inspiration, and the nose in the book and rocking back and forth I take from observing Orthodox women. It offers a kind of passionate pleading that helps me focus.
This morning I was listening to the news--only coronavirus--as I began my prayer. All I could do was just sit, my head covered by my tallis. I wondered as I often do, what does my prayer actually do?
At the very least, it helps me to try to be the best person I can be. It may not make me feel better, but it refocuses me to my efforts to be my absolute best, which includes being cheerful and loving towards the family I’m in the house with every day, all day.
Spiritual Lessons from Coronavirus
Sunday, April 19th, 2020
B.C./A.C. (Before Coronavirus/After Coronavirus
I think it’s appropriate for me to begin with my experience of being sick with COVID. After all, this is what inspired me to make a life change--I mean, not total, but just to re-evaluate where I am at this moment and make the big decision to take a year off from official classes at rabbinical school, to begin developing my Hashpa’ah (Spiritual Direction) practice, and to create this here website. I wouldn’t have the time or energy for any of it if it weren’t for that.
So here I am, and here’s my personal story.
I know there are millions, literally millions of stories, as millions have gotten sick with coronavirus over these past months.
I begin with: To remember the blessing of just being alive.
Why is that so hard?
To just be.
It’s true that we are human beings, and not human doings, as Reb Zalman used to like to point out. Maybe the reason we are called “beings” is that we need to be reminded daily of this fact, especially in this doing-driven world we live in. What coronavirus has highlighted even more is that we need to get back to the “being” part.
Before we got sick with coronavirus, I remember thinking with frustration at people’s complaints of being told to stay inside. My heart went out to those who can’t work from home, just barely able to survive, and it still does. It’s truly a privilege to be able to work from home.
I also couldn’t get this image of Anne Frank and her family out of mind, and what it was like to be forced into hiding for years, not even knowing if they would be found and killed. How fortunate are we that we are not under siege (not of this kind, anyway), that we can still access food, that we do not live with the fear of soldiers knocking on our doors and taking us away (not most of us). How grateful that we do not have to stay inside completely, unable to see the light of day. We have iphones and FaceTime and the internet, and delivery systems, even if they are slow at the moment. The slowness and some degree of scarcity that exists are reminders that we have gotten very, very spoiled by the fast delivery system we know we shouldn’t even be using.
Now here I am, after Coronavirus first hit my family, just a few weeks since my husband Oswaldo returned from the hospital, where he was literally on the edge between life and death, and I myself am still experiencing the after-effects of the virus that laid me flat for weeks. And I’m feeling the pressure to get back to “my work.” I haven’t had the brain power to do any reading. Instead, I’ve been savoring the beauty of life, and I must say that this feeling permeates much more of my daily life than was the case before I got Coronavirus.
With my slowly building energy, I have prepared for and cleaned up from Passover, cooked and eaten delicious foods, gone for walks in the sunshine, looked at the blossoms and flowers of springtime. I have been grateful to be alive and for my husband to be with me in the face of so much surrounding death. I remember often that it could have been otherwise. I might have been experiencing an extreme kind of grief at this moment, having lost my husband, unable to comfort myself or my daughters, one who lives with me and another who I wouldn’t be able to see, wondering where my husband’s body was, picturing him in a mass grave, like others I know, unable to have a proper funeral, wondering about my future without him, unable to function.
But I’m not. I’m not. I’m not.
Instead, I remember the incredible joy at having a deep craving for food after weeks of illness, and thinking how good it is to simply have an appetite.
I remember a friend delivering a hamburger she had bought me in the street. How I savored it, how much joy it gave me. For at least a week, all I wanted was meat (and I’m normally mostly vegetarian).
I remember the support of friends, teachers, rabbis, sometimes in the middle of the night.
I remember nights of panic, no sleep, trouble breathing, tracking fevers and blood oxygen levels, watching movies just to keep my mind otherwise occupied, surviving on adrenaline.
I remember phone calls with Oswaldo in the hospital, hearing him getting stronger, crying as I listened to his stories of “seeing the light” and feeling the hundreds of healing prayers from our community, extending around the world.
I remember saying goodbye to him at the door, kissing him on the forehead as the paramedics gave him oxygen. He couldn’t even make eye contact with me. And I remember thinking I might not see him again.
I remember running to the bathroom after frenzied cries from my daughter, finding him passed out in the bathroom, dehydrated from a week of fever, and shaking him back to consciousness, yelling to call 911.
I remember with amazement the three pairs of paramedics that visited our house, bringing peace, calm, caring and kindness, despite the personal risk to themselves.
I remember breaking down with Rebecca when we closed the door behind him, crying out, “Him, of all people...he’s supposed to be the strong one…!”
I remember calling Dina, my reiki teacher and friend, and crying with her as I told her that they’d taken him away to the hospital, because that’s how it felt: like they’d taken him away. Dina immediately gathered her “forces” and within 20 minutes, she was surrounding Oswaldo, and then me and Rebecca, with healing energy. Afterwards she told me that Mother Mary had shown up right away to pour her healing energy into Oswaldo. (She was sorry, but Mother Mary was Jewish.)
I remember community members and friends shopping for us, picking up necessities.
I remember that Friday when Oswaldo went to the hospital. A community member had shopped for us for Shabbat. I don’t know how, but after the reiki, Rebecca and I were somehow able to enjoy our meal, reassured that Oswaldo was getting the care he needed, energetically, spiritually, and physically, after 6 harrowing days. and eating the potato kugel, chicken soup and rotisserie chicken with such gusto. There had been two visits from paramedics, a visit to Urgent Care, and finally the third call to 911 when he finally couldn’t fight anymore and agreed to go to the hospital.
I remember the night of trying to keep his fever down, torturing him with icy washcloths on his body as he shivered, and pounding on his back to loosen the pneumonia, all while I was still sick and weak myself.
I remember the gratefulness I felt for his healing, and for the nurses and doctors and other caretakers in the hospital who gave such love and care despite their fear for their own lives and families.
All this gave me hope for humanity, despite the ongoing horrible news, despite our government and our president.